Springfield, Illinois, residents know hailstorms can strike fast and cause serious damage. Sangamon County sees frequent severe weather with hail events that dent, crack, and destroy roofs—sometimes even dime-sized hail leads to granule loss, leaks, or full replacements.
At Capital City Roofing & Solar, we’ve handled hundreds of hail damage claims and roof replacements right here in Central Illinois. When it’s time for a new roof, the top question we hear is: “Should I go with metal roofing or asphalt shingles for better hail protection?”
In this post, we break down metal vs. shingles specifically for Springfield’s hail-prone climate. We’ll spotlight two standout options we install: CertainTeed Landmark Pro shingles (with Class 3 impact resistance and insurance discounts) and Mansea Metal roofing from nearby Mt. Zion, IL (with outstanding warranties).
Why Hail Resistance Matters in Springfield
Hail isn’t just a cosmetic issue—it shortens roof life, voids warranties, and triggers insurance claims. Standard shingles often crack or lose granules after repeated storms. Impact-resistant materials reduce damage, lower repair costs, and can qualify you for new-roof insurance discounts. Choosing the right system now protects your home, your wallet, and your peace of mind for decades.
Asphalt Shingles: CertainTeed Landmark Pro – Strong Hail Protection + Insurance Savings
Asphalt shingles remain the most popular choice for good reason: they’re affordable, come in beautiful styles and colors, and install quickly.
For hail resistance, we strongly recommend CertainTeed Landmark Pro premium architectural shingles.
Here’s Why They Stand Out in Springfield:
• UL 2218 Class 3 impact resistance – Tested to withstand significant hail impacts without major cracking or granule loss.
• Class 3 New Roof insurance discount – Many Illinois carriers offer premium reductions for homes with new Class 3 impact-rated roofs. This can save you hundreds per year—ask your insurer about the “Class 3 new roof” credit when you replace.
• 50-year warranty coverage – With proper installation by a certified contractor like Capital City Roofing & Solar, you get extensive material and workmanship protection (including enhanced SureStart® programs).
• Bonus features: Class A fire rating, advanced algae resistance, and excellent wind ratings.
Pros of Landmark Pro shingles:
• Lower upfront cost than metal
• Traditional look homeowners love
• Qualifies for insurance discounts right away
Cons:
• Still more vulnerable to very large or repeated hail than metal (though far better than basic shingles) If you want reliable hail protection without the higher price tag of metal, Landmark Pro is an outstanding choice.
Metal Roofing: Mansea Metal from Mt. Zion – Built to Take the Hits
Metal roofing has become a favorite in hail-heavy areas like Central Illinois—and for good reason. It simply handles impact better.
We proudly install Mansea Metal products, manufactured right in Mt. Zion, IL (just a short drive from Springfield).
Their High-Quality Steel Panels Deliver:
• Superior hail resistance – Metal panels resist cracking, puncturing, or granule loss. Even if large hail causes minor cosmetic dents, the roof’s waterproof integrity stays intact.
• Outstanding warranties – 25-year Galvalume substrate warranty + 40-year Sherwin-Williams WeatherXL paint warranty (covers fading, chalking, and peeling).
• Long lifespan (often 40–70+ years with minimal maintenance)
• Excellent energy efficiency and wind resistance
Pros of Mansea Metal roofing:
• Best-in-class hail and storm durability
• Extremely low maintenance
• Perfect pairing with solar panels (we specialize in solar + metal roof combos)
• Modern or classic styles available
Cons:
• Higher initial investment
• Slight noise during heavy rain/hail (easily reduced with proper underlayment)
For homeowners who want maximum longevity and the least worry about future hail damage, Mansea Metal is tough to beat.
Bottom line: Both options protect far better than basic shingles. Landmark Pro gives you great value and immediate insurance savings. Mansea Metal offers unmatched long-term durability and hail performance.
Why Springfield Homeowners Choose Capital City Roofing & Solar
We’re a local, veteran-owned company serving Springfield and all Central Illinois. Whether you need hail damage restoration, a full roof replacement, or a new metal roof ready for solar, our team handles the entire process—from insurance claims to expert installation.
We install both CertainTeed Landmark Pro and Mansea Metal and helped you pick the best fit for your home, budget, and style. Plus, we understand local weather patterns and work directly with insurers to maximize your discounts.
Ready to Storm-Proof Your Roof?
Don’t wait for the next hail warning. Schedule a free roof inspection and consultation with Capital City Roofing & Solar today. We’ll evaluate your current roof, discuss metal vs. shingles options, explain your insurance discount eligibility, and give you honest recommendations.
Call us at 217.425.2496 or visit our website to get started. Protect your home, save on insurance, and enjoy peace of mind through every Springfield storm.
Capital City Roofing & Solar – Your local experts in hail-resistant roofing and solar in Springfield, IL.